If you want to own Bitcoin itself and might one day move it to your own wallet, open a crypto exchange account. If you want Bitcoin sitting next to your index funds, on the same tax paperwork and eligible for an IRA, use a brokerage account and buy a spot Bitcoin ETF. Price is not the real difference. Three things are: who holds the coins, whether you can ever take them out, and which tax form shows up in February.

A third path now sits between those two. Large brokerages have started selling actual Bitcoin, not just funds, through crypto accounts linked to your regular brokerage account. Charles Schwab began rolling this out in April 2026. It's convenient, but at launch you couldn't withdraw the coins. On the question that matters most, that puts it closer to the ETF than to an exchange.

This page puts the three routes side by side, using what reviewers, regulators and the IRS have published. Then it says which route suits which reader.

The three routes side by side

Each column uses one example that the sources document in detail. Fees at other exchanges, and what they come to on a real purchase, are in the sections below.

Crypto exchange (Coinbase) Brokerage crypto account (Schwab) Spot Bitcoin ETF in a brokerage account
What you own Bitcoin credited to your account and held by Coinbase Bitcoin held by Schwab as custodian, with Paxos doing execution and sub-custody Shares of a fund that holds Bitcoin
Who holds the underlying Bitcoin Coinbase Schwab, with Paxos as sub-custodian The fund's custodian. Coinbase Custody holds 80 to 84% of all US spot Bitcoin ETF assets (Bitwise, via KuCoin)
Withdraw Bitcoin to your own wallet Yes No, deposits and withdrawals were disabled at launch in April 2026 (The Block) No, you hold shares, not coins
Published trading cost 1.84% all-in on the simple buy screen; 0.6% maker and 1.2% taker on Advanced (Yahoo Finance, 2026) 0.75% per trade (The Block, April 2026) Charged as an ordinary brokerage share trade, with fund costs set by each issuer
Coins on offer 240 to 256 crypto assets (Finder) Bitcoin and ether only at launch Bitcoin exposure only
SIPC protection None for Bitcoin held at a crypto firm (Protos) None for the Bitcoin: SIPC covers securities, and FDIC covers only bank deposits The shares, up to $500,000 per customer if the brokerage fails; not the Bitcoin's price or theft at the custodian (Protos)
IRS form for sales Form 1099-DA, gross proceeds from 2025 sales, cost basis from 2026 sales Form 1099-DA, as a custodial broker Brokerage reporting on the 1099-B system; most grantor-trust crypto ETFs are not 'covered securities', so basis reporting may be limited (The Tax Adviser)
Availability US-based exchange, founded 2012 (Finder) Not offered in New York or Louisiana at launch Any brokerage that lists the fund

The ETF trading-cost cell is not a figure because none of the sources behind this page published fund expense ratios or per-share commissions. Check the fund's fact sheet and your brokerage's commission schedule before you compare it against the other two percentages.

How a crypto exchange works, and what Coinbase, Kraken and eToro charge

A crypto exchange is a marketplace where buyers and sellers are matched against each other. The matching runs through an order book, a live list of every price at which people are currently willing to buy and sell.

You can place two kinds of order. A market order says "buy now at whatever the best available price is" and fills immediately. A limit order says "buy only at this price or lower" and waits on the book until someone takes the other side.

That difference drives the fee schedule. A limit order that waits on the book adds supply, so it pays the lower maker fee. A market order that fills against someone else's waiting order removes supply, so it pays the higher taker fee.

Most exchanges also offer a simple "buy" button for beginners, and that is where the real cost sits. The button doesn't use the order book directly. It quotes a price with a spread, a markup over the market price, and often adds a fee on top. According to Yahoo Finance's 2026 roundup, the published figures were:

  • Coinbase: about 1.84% all-in on the beginner screen (a 0.84% fee plus a 1% spread). On Advanced, 0.6% maker and 1.2% taker. Debit card deposits cost 4.2%.
  • Kraken: about 2% per trade on the beginner screen (1% fee plus 1% spread). On its advanced tier, 0.25% maker and 0.4% taker. Debit card deposits cost $0.25 plus 3.75%.
  • eToro: a flat 1% for beginner and advanced trading alike, and free debit card deposits.
  • Uphold: 1.8% to 3.8%, with a 3.99% debit card deposit fee.

All four exchanges took bank transfers for free.

The beginner screen can cost more than those averages suggest. NerdWallet's November 2026 fee guide reports that a $200 instant buy on Coinbase, funded by ACH, came to about $5.68: a 1% spread plus a $3.68 flat fee, or roughly 2.84%. Finder puts Coinbase's instant-buy fees at up to 3.99% plus spread.

Bitpanda, a Europe-focused exchange, charged about 0.99% plus spread on instant buys as of August and September 2026, per CryptoTicker's fee summary. Its order-book tier started at 0.25% and fell to 0.02% for high-volume traders. Those figures come from third-party aggregators, not from Bitpanda's own fee page.

Uphold is where the published numbers disagree most. Yahoo Finance lists 1.8% to 3.8%. Another aggregator reports 0.8% to 1.2%. NerdWallet lists a range of 0.5% to 5.5%, and in one purchase measured an effective cost of about 0.505%. Spread-based pricing explains the gap: the cost moves with the market and the payment method, so no single figure holds. The only way to settle it is to compare the quoted price against the market price on the day you buy.

Who an exchange suits: someone who wants to own the coin, may move it to their own wallet, and will use limit orders to keep the fee near the maker rate.

Pros
  • You own Bitcoin you can withdraw to a wallet you control
  • Maker fees on advanced screens are among the lowest published: 0.25% at Kraken, 0.6% at Coinbase
  • Free bank-transfer deposits at Coinbase, eToro, Uphold and Kraken (Yahoo Finance)
  • Reports to the IRS on Form 1099-DA, the same system brokerages now use for crypto
Cons
  • Simple-buy screens cost 1.84% to about 2.84% at Coinbase in published figures
  • Debit card funding adds 3.75% to 4.2% at Coinbase, Kraken and Uphold
  • No SIPC protection for Bitcoin held at the exchange
  • Can't hold the coin inside an ordinary IRA

How a brokerage prices Bitcoin, and what Schwab's crypto account changed

A broker doesn't hand you an order book. It quotes one price and charges you one of three ways: a spread built into the price, a flat percentage commission, or, for very large orders, a private trade through an over-the-counter (OTC) desk. An OTC desk fills a large order directly with a counterparty so the order doesn't move the public market price. The sources behind this page don't publish a current dollar threshold for OTC desks, so ask the broker directly if your purchase is large.

An ordinary stock brokerage used to offer Bitcoin only through funds. That changed when the SEC and FINRA withdrew their earlier guidance on broker-dealer crypto custody. A Sullivan & Cromwell memo on the change says it helps explain why Schwab, Fidelity and Robinhood were able to expand into direct spot Bitcoin trading and custody in 2026.

Schwab is the best-documented case. The Block reported that the rollout began on April 16, 2026, and ran in phases over several weeks. As launched:

  • You buy in a dedicated crypto account, offered by Charles Schwab Premier Bank and linked to your Schwab brokerage account.
  • Schwab acts as custodian. Paxos handles execution and sub-custody.
  • The fee is 75 basis points, or 0.75% per trade.
  • Only Bitcoin and ether are available.
  • You can't transfer coins in or out. Schwab said it plans to allow transfers but gave no date.
  • Residents of New York and Louisiana can't use it.

The sources here don't publish current fees or withdrawal rules for Fidelity's or Robinhood's crypto accounts, so this page doesn't compare them. Check each firm's own disclosure.

At 0.75%, Schwab costs less than Coinbase's simple-buy screen and more than Coinbase or Kraken maker orders. What you give up is the right to take your coins out. Who it suits: an existing Schwab client who wants actual Bitcoin on the same statement as everything else and has no plans to self-custody.

Spot Bitcoin ETFs: the route that skips the coin

A spot Bitcoin ETF is a fund that buys and holds Bitcoin and sells shares in itself on the stock market. You buy the shares like any other ETF, in an ordinary brokerage account or an IRA. You never touch a private key, and you can never withdraw a coin.

Money has been moving this way. Finance Magnates reports that BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust has handled more than $3 billion of in-kind conversions, where large holders swap their Bitcoin directly for fund shares. The same report says self-custodied Bitcoin is falling for the first time in 15 years.

The catch is where the fund's Bitcoin actually sits. Citing Bitwise research, KuCoin News reports that Coinbase Custody holds about 80 to 84% of all US spot Bitcoin ETF assets, roughly $74 billion to $77 billion out of about $91.7 billion. Buying an ETF instead of using Coinbase doesn't remove Coinbase from the picture. It puts Coinbase behind the fund instead of in front of you. The same report notes that no court has yet ruled on how ETF-held coins would be treated if that custodian went bankrupt.

Who it suits: anyone who wants Bitcoin inside a Roth or traditional IRA, or who values one consolidated statement more than holding the coin.

What a $1,000 purchase costs at each published rate

One $1,000 Bitcoin buy, funded by bank transfer

A hypothetical $1,000 purchase, priced at each fee the sources published. Bank transfers were free at all the exchanges Yahoo Finance listed, so the only cost here is the trading fee. Where a source says "plus spread", the spread is extra and isn't counted.

Coinbase simple buy, 2.84% effective (NerdWallet's $200 example)$28.40
Kraken beginner, about 2% (Yahoo Finance)$20.00
Coinbase simple buy, 1.84% all-in (Yahoo Finance)$18.40
Coinbase Advanced, taker 1.2%$12.00
eToro, flat 1% plus spread$10.00 plus spread
Bitpanda instant buy, 0.99% plus spread$9.90 plus spread
Schwab crypto account, 0.75%$7.50
Coinbase Advanced, maker 0.6%$6.00
Kraken advanced, taker 0.4%$4.00
Kraken advanced, maker 0.25%$2.50

The same $1,000 can cost anywhere from $2.50 to $28.40, depending on which screen you click, not just which company you pick. Funding the same buy with a debit card at Coinbase would add 4.2%, another $42.

For someone buying once and holding for a decade, a $20 difference is real money but not what decides the choice. For someone making a $200 purchase every month, it adds up. Paying 2.84% instead of 0.6% on $2,400 a year is about $68 against about $14. If you dollar-cost average on an exchange, learn the limit order on the advanced screen. It's the cheapest habit change on this page.

Who holds the coins, and what happens if they lose them

When you buy Bitcoin on an exchange and leave it there, you own a claim on the exchange, not the coin itself. The exchange holds the private keys and owes you the Bitcoin, much as a bank owes you the balance in your checking account. The difference is that your checking account is insured.

Your Bitcoin is not. Protos lays out the gaps:

  • SIPC, the fund that steps in when a brokerage fails, covers up to $500,000 per customer, including up to $250,000 in cash. It protects securities. It doesn't cover Bitcoin held directly at Coinbase, Kraken or Gemini.
  • For an ETF, "SIPC simply insures the shares." If your brokerage fails, you get your shares back. It doesn't protect the price of Bitcoin, and it doesn't cover the fund's custodian losing coins to theft.
  • FDIC insurance covers bank deposits only and never extends to crypto.
  • Coinbase's own insurance is small next to what it holds. As of February 16, 2024, it held more than $45 billion of customer Bitcoin and had insured about $400 million, roughly 1%. Its $320 million crime policy is shared across institutional and retail custody clients.

The only route here where nobody else holds your Bitcoin is withdrawing it to a wallet you control. Of the three, only the exchange lets you do that. Schwab's account didn't at launch, and an ETF can't. Bitpanda's published fee to withdraw to an external wallet was €2.91 per transaction. For the step-by-step process, the guide to withdrawing BTC from Coinbase covers addresses, test transactions and how other platforms differ.

Which tax form each route sends, and what it leaves out

For most of Bitcoin's history, exchanges sent the IRS far less information than stock brokerages did. That gap is now closing on a fixed schedule.

Under final Treasury regulations (T.D. 10000), any custodial broker, meaning a platform that holds your crypto in order to trade it, has to report your sales on a new form, Form 1099-DA, "Digital Asset Proceeds from Broker Transactions". According to the IRS fact sheet, this covers custodial exchanges, certain hosted wallet providers, crypto kiosks and payment processors. Coinbase falls under it. So does a brokerage crypto account like Schwab's, which holds the coins as custodian. Non-custodial tools such as self-custody wallets are outside it.

How 1099-DA reporting phases in

  1. January 1, 2025
    Gross proceeds reporting begins

    Custodial brokers report what you sold for, but not what you paid. The first forms went out in 2026.

  2. December 31, 2025
    Transition relief for personal records ends

    Notice 2025-7 allowed basis to be identified from your own records only through this date.

  3. January 1, 2026
    Cost-basis reporting begins

    For sales from this date, brokers must also report your adjusted cost basis. Those forms are filed in 2027.

  4. January 1, 2027
    Optional e-delivery without a paper alternative

    Under rules proposed on March 5, 2026, brokers could send 1099-DA electronically without first offering paper. These rules are proposed, not final.

  5. February 2027
    Late-filing grace for some 2025 forms

    Under transition relief, some brokers may issue 2025 Forms 1099-DA up to a year late.

Stock brokerages have reported both proceeds and basis on Form 1099-B for years. CRI Advisors describes 1099-DA as following that framework but trailing it. ETF shares go through the brokerage system, with one wrinkle. The Tax Adviser notes that most crypto ETFs are structured as grantor trusts and aren't "covered securities", so they may not get full cost-basis reporting.

Three rules apply whichever route you choose:

  • Form 8949 is still yours to file. You report each sale's basis and acquisition date yourself, whether or not a 1099-DA arrives.
  • FIFO is the default. Brokers assume you sold your oldest coins first. You can choose specific identification, HIFO or LIFO for Bitcoin, but only if you tell the broker before the sale.
  • Average cost isn't available for Bitcoin itself. It applies only to tokenized funds.

One point has no exception: a sale inside an IRA isn't taxed in the year it happens, whichever brokerage holds it. That advantage belongs to the ETF route, because an ordinary IRA can hold the fund and not the coin.

Minimums, and why the coin list doesn't matter much

Every route lets you start small, though the sources publish only scattered figures:

  • eToro: a $100 minimum deposit, a $5 fee to withdraw cash and a $30 minimum withdrawal (Finder).
  • Coinbase: a £50 minimum deposit on Finder's UK page. NerdWallet describes the US minimum only as "low", without a figure.
  • Bitpanda: a €10 minimum deposit and trades from €1, per Investing.com. Bitpanda says minimums vary by verification status and payment method.
  • Schwab's crypto account: none of the sources publish a minimum.

Coin selection is where the platforms differ most and where it matters least to this reader. Bitpanda lists more than 600 crypto assets, Coinbase lists 240 to 256 and eToro about 100. Schwab launched with two. If your plan is Bitcoin for the long term, a list of hundreds is a list of things you won't buy. A short list can even help, because it removes the temptation.

Should trading money share an account with retirement money?

No. Keep them in separate accounts, and preferably separate firms. The sources don't publish a rule on this. The case comes from how the accounts work.

A retirement account is built for buying and leaving alone. Gains grow without yearly tax, early withdrawals cost you, and an ordinary IRA can hold a spot Bitcoin ETF but not the coin. An exchange account is built for frequent clicking, and it lists hundreds of assets. Put both on one login and one screen, and the retirement balance starts to look like money you could trade with.

In practice, the long-term Bitcoin you want tax-sheltered goes into a spot ETF inside a Roth IRA. Bitcoin you want to hold yourself goes through an exchange and on to a wallet. If you want to speculate at all, do it in neither of those.

Where the three routes really split

Exit rights. Only the exchange lets you withdraw the coin. Everything else follows from that. Without it, your Bitcoin is a balance someone else holds for you. With it, you can take full ownership whenever you choose. The exchange is the one route that keeps self-custody possible later, even if you never use it.

Tax wrapper. Only the ETF fits inside an ordinary IRA. For a reader with decades until retirement, years of untaxed growth outweigh any trading-fee difference on this page.

What you click. Within any one platform, fees vary more than between platforms. Coinbase alone runs from 0.6% to about 2.84% depending on the screen. Schwab's 0.75% beats the simple-buy screens and loses to the maker orders. Once you know which screen to use, cost stops deciding the question.

Insurance doesn't separate them much. SIPC protects ETF shares against a brokerage failure, but none of the three routes protects the Bitcoin itself against loss at a custodian. Most of that custody runs through one company either way.

Which to open

Open a brokerage account and buy a spot Bitcoin ETF if you want Bitcoin in a Roth or traditional IRA, already have money at a brokerage, and never plan to hold your own keys. For most readers with a retirement account and a long horizon, this is the default.

Open a crypto exchange account if you want the coin itself and plan to move some or all of it to a hardware wallet. Fund it by bank transfer, never by debit card, and buy with limit orders on the advanced screen. On published 2026 figures, that's 0.25% maker at Kraken or 0.6% maker at Coinbase, against 1.84% or more on the simple-buy button.

Use a brokerage crypto account like Schwab's only if you want actual Bitcoin on your existing statement, accept that you can't withdraw it, and the 0.75% fee beats the screen you would otherwise use. If withdrawals arrive later, that answer may change.

If the real reason you're here is that a "crypto trading for beginners" search sent you, the honest advice is to skip trading. Pick one of the first two routes, buy on a schedule and hold.

How do you build a Bitcoin position you won't have to trade?

The beginner's guide sets out the long-term ownership plan: how much to hold, through which account and for how long.

Read the Bitcoin for beginners guide